TV Squad article on “Twilight” vs “Roswell”
by Leandra on January 13, 2009
in Cast & Characters, Movie

TV Squad has an article comparing “Twilight” and “Roswell”. It asks the question, “Are aliens more romantic than vampires?”. You can read the article here.
I am a big fan of the old t.v. show “Roswell”, I own all three seasons, and thought the article was interesting.
oh im soo happy you posted this!!! i am still a huge Roswell fan, and it is amazing how twilight has taken over my life now that im grown up just like roswell did when i was a teen…before I read the twilight saga i was watching the 3 seasons of roswell and making my husband watch them lol..so he’s glad i moved on.
now Max Evans vs. Edward Cullen…
it’s a toughie…just because I’m so infatuated with Edward he would win right now…but in a few years when I’ve calmed down a bit…then i can make a clear choice.
thanx for that post!
I love Roswell! (still!) I was so sad to see it go. I have all the dvd’s and love to grag them out whenever I see one of the actors in something new. Max was romantic when he thought it was “safe” but he pushed Liz away most of the time. I think Edward has him beat in that department. Once he gave in he really didn’t look back (after New Moon…) Both are great!
ARE THEY MENTAL!!!!! OF COURSE ROSWELL IS MORE ROMANTIC!!! SIKE!! OH SNAP I CANT DECIDE, I LOOVED ROSWELL BUT…. DARN….. I LOVE TWILIGHT TOOO….OK I HAVE DECIDED!!!…………… DRUMROLL PLEASE……..
BOTH!!
ok ok ok ok TwIlIgHt alright you crazy freaks will not understand how wonderful twilight is if i met any of the cast i would never let go all the guys i know hate twilight cuz i love it kk so shut up the choice has been chosen twilight hellloooo sexiest vampire ummmmm robert pattinson duhhhhhhh and aliens are green not ummm normal kk so shut up and realize twilight is the best book and the best movies kk!!!!
VAMPIRES ARE MORE HOT AND ROMANTIC!!!ROSWELL,ANG PODI MO!!!
EDWARD CULLEN HOT,MAX EVANS NOT!!!HAHAHA!!!
OMG. Whoever thought aliens were cuter than vampires need to be locked up in that mental institution 3 blocks from my house, and also I think robert pattinson is the hottest vampire.
if its about looks, then of course Robert Pattison has Jason Behr beat…
character wise, theyre neck and neck…but yes I’d have to agree once Edward came back after new moon he gave in completely…max evans cant compete in that sense.
I have never seen “Roswell”, so I *have* so pick TWILIGHT!! I thought it rocked!!
:[
You know what if they made Twilight as a Series i think it would be way better then the movies…Cuz you kinda can take your time instead of having to cut parts out and change parts from the book. It was very disappointing when they did that. Especially the meadow part. I would have loved Twilight to be a series. I think you would have felt more of the emotions that you felt in the book if it was a series. So they really should make twilight a series. Roswell was way good just picture Twilight!
EDWARD IS SEXY
yeah, i have to agree with wanda he is so sexy he has the body that the other boy`s want.
i am a fan of both stories!!and they are really quite the same bcoz:the non-human guy(max/edward) exposed his unusualness by saving the girl’s(liz/bella)life, they are in highschool,the girl lives w/ her father, the father is kind of against the guy,there’s highschool graduation, they got married after graduation,the girl eventually become one of the guy’s family/kind (bella became a vampire,liz got some alien powers since max saved her life).there..its the similarities i can think as of the moment,hehe..i love Edward better though but, i hate it when bella stays in love w/ jacob..liz wasn’t like that
I guess the people saying that Twilight is better than Roswell havent really watched Roswell, or it’s some silly teenagegirl who doesnt care about anything than how hot the guys are (which in my opinion the twilight guys are NOT! and for those saying that Edward/Robert got a nice body in that movie, wtf have you been smoking, or is it because you actually never saw a goodlooking guy with a nice body before?!).
When I was reading the books, I imagined Shiri Appleby and Jason, I was quite disappointed when they choose to use some ugly thing with weird hair as the lead male role, and the worst actress as bella. Oh well I am just happy that the Roswell fans are older and more mature, and doesnt fill up our discussionsboards with 100.000.000 msgs saying “I <3 you Rob" or "<3<3<3<3 Edward", "Team Edward/Jacob (WHATEVER) <3<3<3<3", but can actually have civilised conversations :p