Cast Evolution

by on May 11, 2010
in Cast & Characters

72 Comments
Tweet This - Add to Facebook
Share Post

Iris on Twifans made this very nice graphic with the evolution of the cast of Twilight through the movies.

Which look do you prefer?

Here are my thoughts:

Edward – Eclipse
Bella – New Moon
Taylor – New Moon

Carlisle – New Moon
Esme – New Moon
Emmett – Twilight
Rosalie – Eclipse
Alice – New Moon
Jasper – Twilight

Victoria – New Moon

Comments

72 Responses
  1. shaharEB says:

    first comment!

    • shaharEB says:

      and my thoughts =]
      [my thoughts are on this picture spciffecly]

      Edward – eclipse
      Bella – eclipse
      Taylor –new moon
      Carlisle – new moon
      Esme – new moon
      Emmett –new moon
      Rosalie – twilight
      Alice – new moon

      [my favorite movie is twilight…weird haha=]
      Jasper –
      Victoria –

      • shaharEB says:

        oh i missed jasper-twilight and victoria-hard to choose between new moon and twilight..as long as its racelle its ok!

    • jeimi says:

      Well!I think kind of like u guy’s

      Edward-Eclips

      Bella-Eclips

      Jacob-New Moon

      Rosalie-Eclips

      Emmet-New Moon

      Alice-New Moon

      Jasper-Twilight

      Carlisle-New Moon

      Victoria-New Moon

      Esme-New Moon

    • brittaly says:

      uipjp

  2. NayNay918 says:

    i agree wit ur choices

  3. Team Alice & Jasper says:

    Heres what i thought!!!!!!!!!!!! 😀
    Bella- All of ’em!!!! but i really like her in New Moon if i had to choose 🙂
    Edward- All of ’em (again 😀 ) he looks good in any movie
    Alice- New Moon or Eclipse
    Jasper- New Moon
    Rosalie- New Moon
    Emmett- they all kinda look the same to me, so any of ’em!!!
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Esme- New Moon
    Jacob- he doesn’t really look any diffrent in New Moon and Eclipse, so i guess one of those
    Victoria- New Moon

  4. Courtney Cullen/Black?? says:

    Here are my choices:
    Bella- Eclipse; She looks more mature and I like that because in the books she is described as an adult more than a teenager.
    Edward- (He looks good in any movie, but depending on those pictures exactly) Eclipse; He just looks so much cuter in that picture! I’m lovin’ the V-Neck!!!!!
    Jacob- New Moon or Eclipse; He looks about the same, but I HATE the wig as much as he HATED wearing it! Itchy, anyone??
    Rosalie- Twilgiht; I don’t see why everyone is CRAZYYY about her hair in Eclipse…. it looks better in Twilight! New Moon was ok, but in that ‘Eclipse’ picture her face looks I don’t know…. small?
    Emmett- New Moon; He looks wayyyy better in New Moon!!!
    Alice, Alice, Alice(LOL)- TWILIGHT, TWILIGHT, TWILIGHTTTTTTTT; She is supposed to have SPIKY hair!!!
    Jasper- Twilight; It went downhill from New Moon….
    Carlisle- All of the above; He looks basically the same in all the movies.
    Victoria- New Moon; No it’s not because it is Rachelle… her hair is more flame kind of-red. I don’t see why everyone is making such a big deal out of the new Victoria… she looks fine to me.
    Esme- Twilight; Her hair looks more caramel color!!!
    P.S.
    Rosalie isn’t wearing her necklace in the ‘Eclipse’ picture! WEIRD!

    • ~kxcullen~ says:

      i think all the eclipse pics of the cullens are from when they are practicing for the fight so she wouldn’t be wearing her necklace

  5. Iris says:

    I only disagree with you on Jasper and Alice! I loved Alice in Twilight where she’s just as the character is presented in the books..

    Edward – Eclipse
    Bella – New Moon
    Taylor – New Moon

    Carlisle – New Moon
    Esme – New Moon
    Emmett – Twilight
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Alice – Twilight
    Jasper – New Moon

    Victoria – New Moon

  6. Hannah says:

    Edward Eclipse
    Bella Eclipse
    Jacob New Moon and Eclipse
    Emmett New Moon
    Rosalie New Moon
    Jasper Twilight and New Moon
    Alice Twilight (her hair is the is more like the book)
    Carlisle New Moon
    Esme Twilight

  7. Fundiesz says:

    :))

    Edward – Twilight
    Bella – Twilight
    Taylor – New Moon
    Carlisle – Eclipse
    Esme – Eclipse
    Emmett – Twilight
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Alice – Twilight
    Jasper – New Moon
    Victoria – New Moon

  8. Ashley says:

    Edward – Eclipse – His make-up doesn’t look as harsh.
    Bella – Eclipse – I like her wig and make-up better.
    Jacob – New Moon – His skin looks darker like it is supposed to. It looks lighter in Eclipse and Twilight.
    Rosalie – Eclipse – Her hair looks more realistic and she looks prettier.
    Emmett – New Moon or Twilight – He just looks kind of weird in Eclipse.
    Alice – Twilight – I don’t like how her hair isn’t spiky in New Moon and Eclipse. Also she looks older in both New Moon and Eclipse.
    Jasper – Twilight – I like his hair better. I really don’t like his hair style in Eclipse and I kind of don’t like his make-up in New Moon.
    Carlisle – New Moon – I like how his hair is a bit more golden in New Moon. Also his face looks a bit odd in Eclipse.
    Esme – Twilight – I liked her carmel colored wavy hair. I didn’t like how straight it was in New Moon and I don’t like the color for Eclipse
    Victoria – New Moon – I thought her hair was a bit too dull in Twilight. I really like her red hair and how it looks more naturally wavy then it does in Eclipse. I also like the make-up way better. My hate for Bryce being the new Victoria aside, I really don’t like the design of Victoria in Eclipse. I mean her make-up in New Moon actually made her look kind of evil, while in Eclipse she doesn’t look very threatening. Her hair looks like she just got back from a beauty salon with a brand new perm. I really don’t think Victoria would have a very very curly perm. I actually think she looked better and scarier in Twilight than Eclipse.

    Or at least these are my thoughts.

  9. Jasper's Lover says:

    Edward- Eclipse
    Alice- New Moon
    Bella- New Moon
    Jasper- Tie between New Moon and Eclipse. He looks hot in New Moon, but he looks more like Jackson in Eclipse and he IS my fave character! Lol
    Jacob- New Moon
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Rosalie- Not sure. She looks pretty in all of them. Can’t choose.
    Victoria- Eclipse. I like the new one better.
    Emmett- New Moon (Looks too much like my brother in Eclipse)
    Esme- New Moon (Looks like my aunt in Eclipse. Her hair is too dark too…)

  10. serina says:

    EVERYONE LOOKS BETTER IN NEWMOON

  11. Kristin24 says:

    edward eclipse
    bella new moon
    jacob new moon
    rosalie eclipse
    Emmett new moon
    alice twilight
    jasper twilight
    carlisle twilight
    victoria twilight/new moon
    esme new moon

  12. Ashley says:

    Edward – Eclipse
    Bella – Eclipse
    Taylor – Eclipse

    Carlisle – Twilight
    Esme – New Moon
    Emmett – New Moon
    Rosalie – New Moon
    Alice – Eclipse
    Jasper – Twilight

    Victoria – New Moon

  13. Callie says:

    Edward- Twilight
    Bella- New Moon
    Jacob- New Moon/Eclipse
    Rosalie- Eclipse
    Emmett- Twilight (Basically the same look for all of his though)
    Alice- Twilight/New Moon (though I like them all)
    Jasper- Twilight
    Carlisle- Twilight/New Moon Eclipse is okay. And he looks pretty much the same
    Victoria- New Moon
    Esme- Twilight Eclipse is okay…I didn’t like how straight it was for her in New Moon. The darker color in Eclipse bugs me a little…but maybe it’ll look better with the color filter they use?

  14. Taylove says:

    Edward – Eclipse
    Bella – New Moon
    Taylor – New Moon
    Carlisle – New Moon
    Esme – New Moon
    Emmett – Twilight
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Alice – New Moon
    Jasper – Twilight
    Victoria – New Moon

  15. Mariah says:

    Edward- Twilight
    Bella- Twilight
    Jacob- Eclipse
    Rosalie- Twilight
    Emmet- Twilight
    Alice- Twilight
    Jasper- New Moon
    Carlisle- Twilight
    Victoria- New moon
    Esme- Eclipse

  16. Chelsea says:

    My overall is New Moon. 🙂

  17. lurdes says:

    love the pic all the s\cast transformed in new styles OMG

  18. Kelsi says:

    I think everyone looks better in New Moon, the pictures look way more better and deeper (if that makes sense). The Eclipse ones are too light

  19. Jasmine says:

    Edward – New Moon
    Bella – New Moon
    Jacob – Eclipse
    Rosalie- Eclipse
    Emmett – Twilight
    Alice – Eclipse
    Jasper – Eclipse
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Victoria – New Moon
    Esme – Eclipse

  20. ShMmm says:

    Bella – New Moon… her face looks better.
    Edward – I don’t really like any but I guess New Moon
    Jacob – New Moon
    Rosalie – Twilight. I don’t really like that pic but how she looked on Bella’s first day.
    Emmett – Twilight
    Jasper – New Moon
    Alice – New Moon
    Carlisle – Twilight, not that pic but his first scene and stuff
    Esme – Twilight
    Victoria – New Moon (I HATE BRYCE!)

  21. Darla says:

    i personally think….

    EDWARD LOOKS FRIGGIN’ HAWWWWT IN ALL OF THEM!!!!!
    :):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):)

  22. Debbie says:

    I like them all exspecialy Alice in Eclipse

  23. Mrs.Tim Urban says:

    my thoughts: Edward Eclipse and Alice Eclipse. the rest all new moon <3

  24. Angel says:

    Edward – Eclipse (but I like all of them)
    Bella – All of them
    Jacob – New Moon
    Carlisle – New Moon
    Alice – All of them
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Jasper – New Moon
    Emmett – New Moon
    Esme – Twilight
    Victoria – New Moon

  25. Edward – All of them, but i loved his hair in Twilight
    Bella – All she always looks great!
    Jacob – i dont care after new moon he looks like the same
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Alice – Twilight
    Emmett – New Moon
    Jasper – Twilight
    Carlisle – All he’s such a hottie :]
    Esme – Eclipse
    Victoria – New Moon Rachelle is the best!

  26. Tashana says:

    This is what i think, they all look more amazing.

    Bella Eclipse
    Edward Eclipse
    Jacob Eclipse
    Emmett New Moon
    Rosalie Eclipse
    Carlisle Eclipse
    Esme Eclipse
    Alice Eclipse
    Jasper Eclipse
    Victoria Eclipse

  27. Rosalie Hale says:

    Ily Rosalie, she looks the best in Eclipse because she is really pretty!

  28. Marisa Cullen says:

    Edward- Eclipse He keeps on looking hotter and hotter i can’t decide but I’m going with Eclipse)
    Bella-Eclipse OR New Moon (but in Twilight she look really young and almost vampire)
    Alice-New Moon OR Eclipse
    Jasper- New Moon (his hair looks too long and it seems like he isn’t a vampire)
    Rosalie-Eclipse (her hair is really nice)
    Emmett-New Moon (His hair looks weird in Eclipse)
    Carlisle-New Moon OR Eclipse (in twilight he looked like a ghost)
    Esme-New Moon (I like her hair straight)
    Victoria-New Moon (I Love her hair in New Moon)
    Jacob- I can care less

  29. shelby says:

    Edward-New Moon
    Bella-New Moon
    Jake-New Moon
    Rosalie-New Moon
    Emmett-Twilight
    Alice-Twilgiht or New Moon
    Jasper-Twilight! i absolutely hate the eclipse hair. 🙁
    Carlise-Twilight
    Victoria-Twilight hair, New Moon color!
    Esme-Twilight or New Moon

    this kinda makes me sad, cause i don’t like anything in eclipse, character wise, hopefully once i see the movie ill feel different!!(:
    ?Shelby

  30. Marisa Cullen says:

    Edward-Eclipse + New Moon
    Bella-New Moon + Eclipse
    Alice- All three
    Jasper- New Moon
    Rosalie-Eclipse + New Moon
    Emmett-New Moon
    Carlisle-Eclipse And New Moon
    Esme-New Moon
    Victoria-New Moon
    Jacob-Don’t Care!

  31. Marisa Cullen says:

    I Love Edward

  32. Marisa Cullen says:

    TEAM EDWARD!

  33. Corinn says:

    Here’s my thoughts..

    Edward-Eclipse
    Bella-Eclipse
    Jacob-Eclipse
    Rose-Twilight
    Emmet-New Moon
    Alice- ALL OF THEM
    Jasper-New Moon
    Carlisle-All of Them
    Victoria-Twilight
    Esme-Twilight and/or Eclipse

  34. Anne^^. says:

    ok, so my thoughts are:
    Edward- ECLIPSE! he’s looking soo good 😀 but still, he looks great in ALL OF THE MOVIES!
    Bella- NEW MOON! definitely. or PROOOOOBABLY eclipse.
    Jacob- he looks like the same in NEW MOON & ECLIPSE. so either one.
    Rosalie- ECLIPSE! no discussion. she looks sooooooo gorgeous!
    Emmett- umm NEW MOON! totally. he looks good in eclipse, tho.
    Alice- ALL OF THEM! but if i haaadd 2 choose it’d be ECLIPSE, or NEW MOON!!!! (yea, she’s lookin great in new moon).
    Jasper- tottaaally NEW MOON! and then eclipse! <3 *crush*
    Esme- NEW MOON. or TWILIGHT. she looks sweeter. but she looks awesome in all anyway!
    Carlisle- NEW MOON. or ECLIPSE. i dont really know.
    Victoria- NEW MOOON!!!!!!!!!!!! definitely. totally LUV HER! (not bryce!)
    :] so i guess NEW MOON's like the best OR ECLIPSE. yepp.

  35. Ayleen Cullen says:

    YOU PUT TAYLOR, AND NOT JACOB!
    ROFL:D

  36. Vanessa Cullen says:

    Based on the pictures, my choices are:

    Edward-New Moon
    Bella-New Moon
    Jacob-New Moon(He looks way better with short hair)
    Rosalie-New Moon
    Emmett-Twilight
    Alice-New Moon
    Jasper-Twilight
    Carlisle-New Moon
    Esme-New Moon
    Victoria-New Moon

  37. team jacob/taylor says:

    jacob- new moon and eclipse
    bella-new moon
    edward-eclipse
    alice- twilight
    rosalie- she looks good in all
    jasper- twilight (i don’t like his hair in eclipse)
    emmet-new moon
    victoria-new moon
    carlisle- new moon and eclipse
    esme-twilight

  38. Ryan Maroldi says:

    Why does Emmet look like a homo in eclipse isnt he suppose to be the intimidating one? COme on now

  39. mag says:

    OMG nooo nooo they all look PLAIN!!!!!! im sry but iliked them all WAY! beta in New Moon and twilight!

  40. Ellie says:

    Here are my thoughts: (But i still think Riley is hotter than them all!!!)

    Edward- New Moon
    Bella- Eclipse
    Jacob- New Moon
    Rosalie- New Moon
    Emmett- Twilight
    Alice- New Moon
    Jasper- New Moon
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Victoria- New Moon
    Esme- New Moon

    Though I just love them all!!!

  41. gabby says:

    wow i love it so much jacob looks better and better every time

  42. momoi asaivao says:

    and my thoughts…

    EDWARD | new moon
    BELLA | new moon
    JACOB | new moon
    ROSALIE | new moon
    EMMETT | new moon
    ALICE | new moon
    JASPER | new moon
    CARLISLE | new moon
    VICTORIA | new moon
    ESME | new moon

    oh…look at the ALL new moon 8)

  43. lilo says:

    everyone looked their best in twilight… yes. Jacob too. don’t like him when all he does in new moon is flashing his fake abs so all the girls that were team edward chose jacob only for his fkin abs. so mad that all people do is getting after looks.

    • ~kxcullen~ says:

      i know that is sooo annoying how everyone was all of a sudden team jacob JUST because taylor got some musscle!

  44. Eliza Cullen says:

    Edward-New Moon
    Bella-Eclipse
    Jacob-Eclipse
    Rosalie-Eclipse
    Emmett-New Moon
    Alice-Eclipse
    Jasper-New Moon
    Carlisle-New Moon
    Victoria-New Moon
    Esme-New Moon

  45. Robfan says:

    Edward- New moon
    Bella- New moon
    Jasper – Twilight
    Carlisle- Twilight
    Esme – New Moon
    Emmette- New Moon
    Rosalie- Twilight
    Alice- Twilight
    Jacob- New Moon
    Victoria- New Moon

  46. Arianna says:

    I completely greed with you Leandra

    They all look more like vampires on Eclipse lol
    The only one that actually don’t like how look now is Jasper…
    But my favorite look of all is new moon

  47. JRo says:

    I think New Moon is the best for all of them (except Jasper, Twilight all the way for him). They all look more like vampires in New Moon.

  48. Cassie says:

    Going on not only these pictures but on every thing ive seen of all 3 films :

    Edward- Twilight
    Bella- New Moon
    Jacob- New Moon
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Esme- Eclipse
    Emmette- New Moon
    Rosealie- Eclipse
    Alice- Twilight
    Jasper- Eclipes
    Victoria- Twilight

    On these pictures only:

    Edward- New Moon
    Bella- New Moon
    Jacob- New Moon
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Esme- New Moon
    Emmette- New Moon
    Rosealie- New Moon
    Alice- New Moon
    Jasper- Twilight
    Victoria- New Moon

    • Cassie says:

      Forgot ti wright this lol :

      I like Victoria’s hair coulor better in Twilight as I think it looks more natural.
      Although this picture doesant show it off very well I love Esme’s darker hair in Eclipes I think it lovely.
      Alice’s hair does look good in all 3 films but I think it looks more pixie like in Twilight whitch was the description and more how I pictued it.
      Again although this picture doesant do it ny justice I feel that Jaspers hair in Eclipes is more how It is described in the books.
      Rosealies hair looks great up in a couple of other Eclipes photos ive seen.

      These are just my owne personal opinions though xxx

  49. Siret says:

    My favourites are:

    Edward – Twilight
    Bella – New Moon
    Taylor – New Moon
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Emmett – Twilight (don’t like Emmet’s Eclipse photo at all)
    Alice – New Moon
    Jasper – Twilight (hate Jasper’s wig in Eclipse)
    Carlisle – New Moon
    Esme – Twilight
    Victoria – New Moon

  50. Manda_panda says:

    Here are my thoughts:

    Edward – Eclipse
    Bella – New Moon
    Taylor – New Moon
    Carlisle – New Moon
    Esme – New Moon
    Emmett – Twilight
    Rosalie – Eclipse
    Alice – New Moon
    Jasper – Twilight
    Esme – Eclipse
    Victoria – New Moon

  51. VampireGirl98 says:

    Edward-Eclipse
    Bella-New Moon
    Jacob-New Moon
    Rosalie-Twilight
    Emmett-New Moon
    Alice-According to the book in Twilight she had the appropriate hairstyle,but I like her in Eclipse!
    Jasper-Twilight
    Carlisle-New Moon
    Victoria-New Moon
    Esme-New Moon

  52. ~kxcullen~ says:

    edward-eclipse
    bella- twilight (she looks the most vulnerable)
    jacob- new moon (hes wolfy jake but he’s not as hard as eclipse)
    rosalie-eclipse
    emmett-newmoon
    alice-twilight (her hair is the best!)
    jasper-eclipse
    carlise-twilight (his hair is better)
    victoria- newmoon (it’s rachelle with proper victoria hair!)
    esme-twilight/eclipse (just the right amount of make up)

    i think the vampires look the best in the eclipse pics because the actually look like vampires! in twilight the look too normal! and in new moon they have kind of a shine to there face but in eclipse there pale and stuff and i think their “look” works the best apart from emmett his hair cut looks like a bowl cut! lol!

  53. Bella Cullen says:

    Edward- Eclipse
    Bella- Eclipse
    Rosalie- Eclipse
    Emmett- New Moon
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Esme- Eclipse
    Alice- Twilight
    Jasper- Eclipse
    Victoria- Twilight (NO BRYCE, RACHELLE FOREVER!)
    Jacob- Eclipse

  54. claudya says:

    Edward-New Moon
    Bella-Eclipse
    Jacob-Eclipse
    Jasper-Twilight
    Rosalie-Eclipse
    Alice-New Moon
    Carlisle-New Moon
    Esme-New Moon
    Victoria-New Moon
    Emmett-New Moon

  55. T says:

    I like all of them best in New Moon, except Jasper and Alice were better looking in Twilight.

  56. Erica says:

    Edward: New Moon
    Bella: Eclipse
    Alice: Twilight
    Jasper: Twilight
    Carlisle: New Moon
    Esme: New Moon
    Emmett: Eclipse
    Rosalie: Eclipse
    Victoria: New Moon

  57. TWImore says:

    Edward for Eclipse
    Bella for Twilight
    Jacob for New moon
    Rosalie for Eclipse
    Emmett for Twilight
    Alice for Eclipse
    Jasper for Twilight
    Carlise for New Moon
    Victoria for New Moon
    Esme for Twilight

  58. Mackenzie says:

    Edward:Twilight
    Bella:New Moon
    Jacob:New Moon
    Alice:Twilight
    Rosalie:Eclipse
    Emmett:Twilight
    Jasper:Eclipse
    Carlisle:Eclipse
    Esme:Eclipse
    Victoria: Twilight

  59. jacob'sgirl says:

    edward-eclipse
    bella- new moon
    jacob- new moon and eclipse
    alice- eclipse
    rosalie- new moon
    emmett- new moon
    jasper- twilight
    carlisle- new moon
    esme- twilight
    victoria- eclipse

  60. Savvy05 says:

    Edward:Twilight

    Bella:Eclipse

    Jacob:New Moon

    Alice:Eclipse

    Rosalie:New Moon

    Emmett:Twilight

    Jasper:New Moon

    Carlisle:Twilight

    Esme:Eclipse

    Victoria: New Moon

  61. bella4eva says:

    they all look best in new moon except edward. he looks best in eclipse. they look better with each movie. 🙂

  62. Ann :] says:

    Edward- Eclipse
    Rosalie- Eclipse
    Emmett- New Moon
    Jasper- Eclipse
    Carlisle- New Moon
    Alice- New Moon
    Bella- Eclipse
    Jacob- Eclipse
    Victoria- New Moon
    Esme- New Moon

  63. Gibby says:

    I Think This Is How It Should Have Been Put-
    Edward-Twilight
    Bella-New Moon
    Jacob-Eclipse
    Alice-Eclipse
    Jasper-Twilight
    Rosalie-Eclipse
    Emmett-New Moon
    Carlisle-New Moon
    Esme-Eclipse
    Victoria-New Moon

  64. Alyssa Joy says:

    Here’s what characters look better and what movie:

    Bella- New Moon
    Rosalie- Twilight
    Alice- New Moon
    Jacob- New Moon
    Victoria- Twilight

    Jacob looked cuter with long hair. But I think he would be more better with short hair. He’s cool.

Share Your Thoughts

Personalize your comments with a Gravatar.